According to Amazon shoppers, the mascara doesn’t run, smudge, or flake

Look, we’ve all been there: you leave the house with flawless-looking eyelashes – long ones! Voluminous! Downright dramatic! – only to catch your reflection in the middle of the day and realize that your perfect rhythm has been sabotaged by mascara flakes and smudges. Unfortunately, since “raccoon chic” still isn’t trendy (and probably never will be), it’s time to switch to a formula that will keep you looking fresh for post-work happy hour.

The truth is: not all mascaras are created equal. Some are just better than others. While it may be difficult (and overwhelming!) to figure out which bottles deserve a place in your makeup bag based on the product description, you don’t have to worry about it. You are not a scientist! We looked through thousands of reviews to narrow down the list for you.

Keep scrolling to shop the 8 best mascaras that won’t smudge, run, or flake—all on Amazon, all recommended by shoppers.